Jewsweek, July 18, 2001
"This disturbing story unfolds all too often at the hotline for Migrant
Workers, a Tel Aviv agency founded in 1998 to protect the human rights of
foreign workers, victims of sex trafficking among them ... Director and
co-founder Sigal Rozen, along with the group's counsel, Nomi Levenkron, were
in Washington, D.C. ...
In an interview, Rozen called sex trafficking an 'unorganized crime,'
based largely on personal networks of immigrants from the Ukraine, Russia,
and Moldova. ... Those three countries alone accounted for 91 percent of the
474 women arrested in brothels and deported from Israel in 2000, according
to figures compiled by hotline volunteers during visits to the Neveh Tirzah
women's prison. These statistics represent only a fraction of the problem.
Police spokespersons have set the number of women brought into the
country to work in the sex industry at 2,000-3,000 annually, the number of
brothels at 250, Rozen said."
Human Rights Abuses Affecting Trafficked Women in Israel's Sex Industry.
Amnesty International, May 18, 2000 [MDE 15/017/2000]
"Although official statistics are not available, it is widely believed
that in the past few years thousands of women, including some girls, from
FSU [former Soviet Union] countries have been trafficked to Israel to work
in the sex industry. Under Israeli laws, virtually all these women are
illegal aliens. They are in Israel without work permits or with false
documents, which makes them particularly vulnerable to human rights abuses
at the hands of traffickers, pimps and others involved in Israel's sex
industry.
Amnesty International has received many reports of trafficked women being
subjected to various human rights abuses, such as enslavement and other
restrictions on their liberty, as well as torture, including rape and other
forms of sexual abuse ...
Amnesty International has received information indicating that in many
instances women trafficked from FSU countries are literally bought and sold
for large sums of money, often in auctions where they are purchased by the
highest bidder. Some are held in debt bondage where they are forced to work
to pay off large sums of money. Some women are kidnapped against their will
in FSU countries or are lured to Israel under false pretences, and brought
to work in the sex industry.
Their 'owners' restrict their movements in order to prevent them from
leaving. There are many reports of women being imprisoned by their 'owners'
in locked houses and apartments and prevented from going out unaccompanied."
Prostitution in the Land of the Maccabees: Trafficking in Women in Israel.
Social Action, [socialaction.com], "a Jewish Online Magazine."
"Today, the prostitute in Tel Aviv is more likely to be named Olga than
Rachel, and she's not an Israeli, or in Israel legally. She's one of the
more than 2,000 to 2,500 women from former Soviet republics brought into
Israel by international traffickers to feed a $450 million-a-year
prostitution industry centered around Tel Aviv.
The money paid for her body goes to the man she's been sold to. Assault
and rape are common ways of keeping 'employees' in line in this business,
and the only way a woman will leave Israel's sex industry is if she comes to
the attention of the Israeli authorities who will deport her, penniless and
traumatized, back to Eastern Europe ...
Very rarely, a particularly horrific story will make its way from the
Israeli press to American Jewish listserves. When the most recent of these
motivated me to get out there and see what I could do to help, I discovered
that there is apparently no Jewish organization in the United States or
Canada working to raise awareness of trafficking issues in Israel, or bring
American Jewish money and influence to bear on the situation. Why should
this be an issue for the American Jewish community? After all, most of the
women affected are not Jewish."
Factbook on Global Sex Exploitation: Israel. Coalition Against
Trafficking in Women
"Traffickers and pimps earned US$50,000 - 100,000 a year from each
prostituted woman, resulting in a US$450 million sex industry. ('A modern
form of slavery,' The Jerusalem Post, 13 January 1998)
1,500 Russian and Ukrainian trafficked women have been deported from
1995-1997. (Michael Specter, 'Traffickers' New Cargo: Naive Slavic Women,'
New York Times, 11 January 1998)
Russian women are bought and sold by pimps in Israel for prices ranging
from US$5,000 to $20,000. (Police sources, ''Invisible' Women Shown In
Russia's Demographics,' Martina Vandenberg, St. Petersburg Times, 13 October
1997)
A small brothel with ten women can make up to 750,000 shekels a month (US
$215,000). (Michael Specter, 'Traffickers' New Cargo: Naive Slavic Women,"
New York Times, 11 January 1998)
Women trafficked from Eastern Europe, were stripped and sold naked as
slaves to Tel Aviv traders for US$500-1,000. Smuggling, fraudulent
documents, collaboration between police and brothel owners are involved.
There are routine brutal beatings and sexual abuse. (New York Times
11 January 1998)."
BGU Publishes First Study of local Prostitutes. Jerusalem Post,
July 31, 2001
"A first-ever Israeli academic study on the medical and emotional
condition of prostitutes has found that most risk HIV and hepatitis C
infection through unprotected oral sex, and many suffer from depression and
post-traumatic stress disorder ...
They reported in private interviews of having an average of 12 clients a
day during the week, and during peak days (weekends and holidays) about 30
in a 24-hour period. Two-fifths worked daily except for a single day off a
month. They earned a monthly average of only $1,285, and those with family
abroad sent most of it to support them, while their personal expenses were
paid by the brothel owners."
Cantor Charged in Prostitution Ring. Jerusalem Post, January 31,
2000
"Members of Chicago's Jewish community are expressing shock and dismay
about the arrest of a former synagogue cantor and his wife of a few weeks.
The two were charged in connection with a prostitution ring. Joel Gordon,
51, who has served at several Chicago-area synagogues, was charged November
21 with keeping a house of prostitution following a police raid on three
massage parlors, operated out of private apartments in the northern suburbs.
His wife, Alison Ginsberg, 23, was charged with prostitution and keeping a
house of prostitution. Gordon was most recently the cantor and spiritual
leader of Congregation Shirat Emet, a now-defunct synagogue in the Chicago
suburb of Buffalo Grove, Illinois."
Federal Prosecutors Try to Keep Boca Rabbi Jailed, Calling Him a
Menace. Ft. Lauderdale Sun-Sentinel, July 20, 2001
"Responding to a jailed rabbi's appeal that he be allowed to await trial
in a psychological program, federal prosecutors this week argued that
Jerrold Levy remains a threat to the community and a flight risk ...
Prosecutors said they have developed additional evidence that Levy
distributed child pornography to other people, received child pornography
from a minor contacted in an Internet chat room, and pursued other minors
... In their response to Levy's appeal, prosecutors said there is
'overwhelming' evidence against Levy to support their existing nine charges
of child pornography and using the Internet to entice a juvenile. Last week,
Levy, a former associate rabbi at Temple Beth El in Boca Raton, filed an
emergency motion for release from prison as he waits to hear about an
appeal."
Atlanta Strip Club Scandal Marks Return of 'Our Gang.' [Jewish] Forward,
June 29, 2001
"Our boys are still out there, I'm very proud to say,' said Alan Block, a
professor of Jewish studies at the University of Pittsburgh and a noted
authority on Jewish organized crime in America and overseas. They're running
penny-stock scams and providing support for Colombian drug cartels, Mr.
Block said. And they're still, in many cases, chummy with the leaders of the
old time Italian mob.
That is certainly what federal prosecutors are alleging against the
flamboyant bar owner Steve Kaplan in the United States district court in
Atlanta ... Prosecutors are trying to prove that the flashy 40-year old used
his popular Atlanta strip club, the Gold Club, as a front for a prostitution
ring that provided high-priced hookers to big name athletes, laundered money
and paid protection money to the Gambino crime family in New York ...
Over the past several years, Jewish names have surfaced in connection
with penny stock scams, in which gangs of aggressive young mobsters corner
the market on low-valued stocks, then drive prices up before unloading them
... The ability to adapt has made Jewish mobsters a more difficult target
for organized crime investigators ... That sense of internationalism, Mr.
Block said, has always been an ace-in-the-hole for Jewish crime syndicates
... Although Jewish mobsters are not immune federal prosecution ...
investigators ... have tended to overlook Jewish connections in organized
crime, Mr. Block said. The result, he said, is that the Jewish American
syndicates have been pretty much free to continue their work in a kind of
comfortable anonymity."
Heidi Fleiss Gets 3 Years. E Online, January 7, 1997
"A Los Angeles judge gave 'Hollywood madam' Heidi Fleiss 37 months for
federal charges of tax evasion and money laundering today, far less than the
7 to 9 years asked by prosecutors. She'll also perform 300 hours of
community service and pay a $400 fine ...Since her arrest, Fleiss has opened
a legitimate business, a lingerie company. On the other hand, she was also
busted for violating probation by using methamphetamine ... Fleiss still
faces state charges of pandering (she was convicted in state court in 1994
but ordered to stand trial again after juror misconduct came to light) ...
The feds claimed that Fleiss laundered at least $300,000 in illicit income
through her family's bank accounts. Her father, pediatrician-to-the-stars
Paul Fleiss, pled guilty to income tax evasion for his role in the scheme."
The Fleiss Family Bed. LA Weekly, April 27-May 3, 2001
"'Children are our ultimate investment,' Los Feliz pediatrician Paul
Fleiss says at a signing for his newly released book, Sweet Dreams: A
Pediatrician's Secrets for Your Child's Good Night's Sleep. 'We want
them to grow up strong and smart. Most importantly, we want them to take
care of us.' This wish hasn't always come true for the gray-, curly-headed
Fleiss, the father of notorious Hollywood Madam Heidi Fleiss. Four months
after Heidi was convicted on felony pandering charges, authorities charged
him with hiding the profits from his daughter's call-girl ring and with
acting as the go-between in the purchase of her home, a $1.6 million spread
once owned by Michael Douglas [son of Jewish actor Kirk Douglas]. Dr. Fleiss
pleaded guilty to making false statements to the IRS and conspiracy, and
received a sentence of three years' probation and community service, which
included volunteering at the Los Angeles Free Clinic. In addition, the
medical board put him on probation for one year."
The Still-Happy Hooker. Moment, February 1, 2001
"[Xaviera Hollander] invited me to Amsterdam to perform, telling me that
she, too, was the child of a Holocaust survivor. When I heard that, I was
speechless. I remembered Xaviera Hollander as a blonde, long-legged
shiksa, the author of a sexually explicit tell-all book-the most famous
prostitute in the world. As it turns out, Hollander (her nom de plume, an
homage to her birthplace; she was born Xaviera De Vries) is no shiksa.
Her father was a Dutch Jewish psychiatrist ... She took a job at a New York
call-girl agency to augment her meager salary, eventually becoming a
full-time prostitute. But it was not just an economic decision: 'I loved
having sex,' she says. 'Since I was sleeping around every night anyway, I
figured I might as well get paid for it.' That's when a business opportunity
came along, and she grabbed it, spending her entire savings-$10,000-on the
client list of a retiring Park Avenue madam. She began running a high-end
brothel out of a brownstone on the Upper East Side, where her clients
included a man who asked a lot of questions, soon arousing Hollander's
suspicion. The man turned out to be Eric Kohn, a Jewish journalist
researching a book. The two decided to collaborate on an autobiographical
account of Hollander's life, and one year later The Happy Hooker
exploded onto the scene-eventually selling 16 million copies ... She even
lived for a while with Penthouse publisher Bob Guccione. But
shortly thereafter she came under the scrutiny of the Knapp Commission,
which had been set up by Mayor John V. Lindsay to investigate malpractice
and corruption in the New York City Police Department. (The commission was
investigating cops who had gone to Hollander's brothel.) Hollander decided
to move to Canada to avoid prosecution ... Addicted to diet pills and unable
to control her kleptomania ('I got orgasms from stealing,' she says), she
was arrested for stealing a $40 nightgown. That theft, coupled with the fact
that she was a confessed criminal in the States, led to her eventual
deportation and divorce."
Traffic Jam, Jerusalem Post, July 13, 2000
"Women who are being forced to work as prostitutes against their will are
considered criminals rather than victims. Kidnapping, threats, forgery,
assault, pimping, rape, and holding prisoners. These are the charges against
18-year-old Boris Yasser from Ashdod, who was remanded last week by Ramle
Magistrate's Court. He is accused of helping his father smuggle four women
into the country from the Ukraine and forcing them to work as prostitutes.
The women (aged 19 to 22) who were subjected to these acts were also
arrested. Their crime was entering the country illegally and holding false
IDs. That they were victimized while they were here does not mitigate the
fact that they violated Israeli law by entering the country illegally,
Central District Police Spokeswoman Ch.-Supt. Sivan Kedmi said ...
The women told police that they had been offered jobs as saleswomen. Upon
accepting the jobs, they were brought here from the Ukraine via Cyprus. They
were smuggled into Haifa Port on April 31. Their employers then confiscated
their passports and gave them fake IDs, which listed them as Jewish
Israelis. Two of the women were 'sold' to a brothel in Tel Aviv for $3,000
each. The other two were imprisoned in a Rishon Lezion apartment and forced
to work as prostitutes. Customers would call the apartment to order
prostitutes. Yasser would drive the women to various locations to serve
between 15 and 20 customers a day. The women were virtual prisoners and did
not receive a share of the money the pimps collected from customers. One of
the women was severely beaten when she tried to escape. She later managed to
telephone her parents in the Ukraine to ask for help. Her parents contacted
the Ukrainian Embassy here, which passed the complaint on to police this
week."
Undercover Police Bust Country's Largest Prostitution Ring,
Ha'aretz (Israel), May 20, 2002
"An undercover police agent who paid NIS 50,000 to purchase rights to use
three women from Moldavia as sex workers, led to the exposure of what police
called Sunday the 'largest prostitution network' to be found in Israel.
Counting this latest sting operation, Tel Aviv police have busted five
prostitution networks in 2002. The major police crackdown in recent months
has tracked down suspects along the entire 'food chain' that thrives on the
exploitation of sex workers. The prostitution racket starts in the CIS;
middlemen fly the women to Egypt; the women are smuggled without any snags
across the border to Israel, where traders wait for them in Eilat; these
salesmen, the last links in the global chain, bring the women to massage
parlor owners in the center of the country. The women, who are usually in
their 20s, get passed from one handler to the next, and undergo physical
abuse and torments which often involves rape perpetrated by traders who want
to check their 'merchandise.'"
Israel: Brisk trade in 'sex slaves', News 24, December 8, 2002
[same story here at
The Globe and Mail]
"About 3,000 women, mainly from the former Soviet Union, are sold each
year into a brisk Israeli sex industry that takes in about $1bn annually, a
parliamentary report said on Sunday, slamming the justice system for being
lax on punishments. The women, seeking to escape poverty at home, are
usually smuggled in by traffickers who promise them legitimate jobs. Once in
Israel, they are sold for between $3 000 and $6 000 each. They receive $25 -
$30 per customer, of which the pimp takes between 80 and 90%, the
preliminary report said. The women work about 12 hours a day, six or seven
days a week and receive an average of 10 to 15 clients daily, it added.
Often, the women live in dismal conditions and sometimes they are physically
abused or live in fear of their pimps, the report said. Israeli courts
generally reach a plea bargain with the pimps and sentence them to either a
few months of community service or up to an average of two years in prison,
punishments which the committee said are too weak to serve as deterrents. It
suggested that these crimes should have minimum prison sentences to deter
the sex traders, who sexually exploit the women and often jail, blackmail
and enslave them. In July 2001, a US State Department report placed Israel
in the third section of its 'black list' on countries whose laws don't meet
US criteria for dealing with this crime and threatened economic sanctions."
Stuck in traffic. Hundreds of women are smuggled into Israel each year
and turned into human property, and hundreds of criminals take part in this
chain of commerce that begins in Eastern Europe and usually ends in a Tel
Aviv brothel. Pitted against them are a handful of police officers, state
prosecutors and judges, all of whom are staggering under an impossible
burden,
by Aviv Lavie, Ha'aretz (Israel), January 5, 2002
"The traffic in women, a thriving sector of the Israeli economy over the
past decade, would apparently have continued to flourish unchecked if not
for three things that took place in quick succession in 2000: Amnesty
International published a report that was very critical about the situation
in Israel in this sphere; the women's lobby did the same; and, finally, Gal
Gabai aired a bloodcurdling report on Channel Two's 'Ulpan Shishi,' in which
traffickers were caught on hidden camera checking out candidates for
purchase, as if the women were chattel at a slave market. Many Knesset
members felt that something had to be done ...
Shortly after it got to work in July 2000, the commission received a
further incentive for its activity, from Capitol Hill in Washington. Every
year, the U.S. State Department presents a report to Congress that describes
the efforts being made by different countries to combat the traffic in human
beings, so this can be taken into account when foreign aid is being
discussed. The 2001 Trafficking in Persons Report dealt Israel a
big blow: The country plummeted to the lowest possible rating, Tier 3, a
group described as 'not making significant efforts to bring themselves into
compliance with the standards of the Victims of Trafficking and Violence
Protection Act of 2000.' Albania, Gabon, Kazakhstan, Malaysia and Pakistan
were some of the countries with which Israel shared this dubious distinction
...
The police speak with frustration about the feeble efforts that are all
they are capable of making against the crime lords. And when they do manage
to haul them in, they end up watching the State Prosecutor's office strike
plea bargains with them. For their part, representatives of the State
Prosecutor's office claimed that the plea bargains were the maximum that
could be achieved, given the severe backlog in the courts. A court system
representative confirmed that the system is jammed and on the verge of
collapse. The picture presented by the protocols is nothing short of
appalling: Hundreds of women are smuggled into Israel each year and turned
into human property; hundreds, if not thousands, of criminals of various
ranks take part in this chain of trade, which begins in Eastern Europe and
usually ends in a Tel Aviv brothel. On the other side are a handful of
police officers, a few diligent state prosecutors and judges who are
staggering under an impossible burden. What chance do they have of
prevailing? ... At the same meeting, the police representatives brought up
another painful matter: the fate of the women enlisted by the police to
testify against the drug dealers and pimps. It turns out that these women
are housed in a hostel where the conditions are barely satisfactory and no
protection is provided."
Sex Trade Flourishing In Holy Land, CBS, February 24, 2003
"After a five-hour drive over the Egyptian desert, Inna crawled through a
tunnel under a border fence, brushed sand off her pants and waited with
seven other women to be taken to their new jobs. Running from poverty in her
homeland of Moldova, Inna had come to the Holy Land to enter a profession as
old as the Bible - prostitution. A $1 billion-a-year sex trade, reputedly
one of the biggest of its kind in the world, has sprung up in Israel over
the past decade. Every year, hundreds of women from eastern Europe and the
former Soviet Union are smuggled into Israel. The trafficking is linked to
the Russian mafia taking root in Israel as a byproduct of mass immigration
from the former Soviet Union. Many of the women are spirited in across
Israel's border with Egypt, which runs along 200 miles of desert that is
difficult to guard against smuggling. The sex trade is so brisk that Israeli
police set up a task force a year ago to deal with human trafficking. 'This
is seriously like slavery,' said Chief Supt. Avi Davidovitch, head of the
task force. Offenders get off too lightly, a parliamentary committee says.
Courts routinely sentence pimps to community service or short prison terms,
the panel said in a report late last year. It called for minimum jail terms
of 16 years. Often, the women are mistreated, held as virtual prisoners and
beaten by pimps, said Ephraim Ehrlich, an intelligence chief in the police
Immigration Bureau. 'The people who work in this field have no conscience.
All they care about is money,' Ehrlich said. 'These girls are really the
victims'
During her six months in Israel, Inna said, she was able to send $3,500
to her mother and sister back in their Moldovan village. That's a small
fortune in her poverty-stricken homeland, where she hopes to build a house
and learn to be a hairdresser. 'After everything I saw here, I don't ever
want to come back,' she said. Asked why she came, Inna said she was
unemployed in Moldova and had come to Israel voluntarily after hearing of
women making money as prostitutes. 'I wanted to do the same thing,' she
said, hooking purple-clad, thin legs behind her chair. 'But it's too
difficult to work with 10 to 15 men a day,' she added, averting her large
brown eyes ... Inna said she did not know how much her pimp paid for her -
although the price can range from $3,000 to $10,000. She said for the first
month, she was paid only $4 per customer because she had to pay off her debt
to the pimp. At a police station in Rehovot, south of Tel Aviv, two other
Moldovan women talked tearfully with reporters about their lives as
prostitutes. One, identified only as Marina, a slightly built 21-year-old,
buried her face in her hands when she revealed that two days earlier she had
learned she was pregnant."
United States Trafficking | Prostitution | Pornography Organized and
Institutionalized Exploitation, Factbook on Global Sexual Exploitation
"25 distinct Russian organized crime groups are operating in the United
States in the areas of prostitution, fraud, money laundering, murder,
extortion and drug trafficking and the Federal Bureau of Investigation has
approximately 250 pending investigations targeting Russian gangs in 27
states. (Barbara Starr, "Former Soviet Union a playground for organized
crime: A gangster's paradise," ABC News, 14 September 1998) ...
Marvin Hersh, a Florida Atlantic University professor, was charged with
alien smuggling and passport fraud for going to Honduras and bringing a
teen-age boy back to Boca Raton, Florida for sex. Affidavits described Hersh
as a longtime pedophile who traveled to Central America and Asia to find
victims. He passed the boy off as his son. Hersh's friend, Nelson Jay Buler,
of Fort Lauderdale, Florida was charged with travelling for the purpose of
illegal sexual contact with a minor, and aggravated sexual abuse of a child
in Honduras. According to Title 18, Section 2423, a federal statute in the
US, it is a crime for any American citizen to travel abroad with the intent
to sexually abuse children. Sentences can be up to 10 years of imprisonment
plus fines of US$ 250,000 ("Bond set for man accused of Honduras
juvenile-sex trips," Associated Press) ...
Roman Israilov of Brooklyn, New York enslaved and raped a 20-year-old
immigrant Russian woman and sexually abused her. He had intended later to
sell her. Police who were notified by a neighbor arrested him. The police
were having problems questioning the woman because she had just recently
arrived and spoke very little English. (Frank Edozien and Larry Celona, "Man
Kept Immigrant as His Sex Slave: Cops," New York Post, 15 September 1997)
Richard Blau, a Manhattan businessman, has been charged with abusing an
immigrant Burmese woman whom he kept chained in his bedroom for nearly two
weeks after offering her work as a cleaning woman. (UPI, 20 August 1997)